In the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York, Judge Analisa Torres dismissed the Mechanical Licensing Collective’s original claim that Spotify misclassified Premium when it added audiobook access, finding Premium is a bundle under Section 115 rules. The court later denied the MLC’s bid for an early appeal but allowed an amended complaint to proceed on different issues: how Spotify values the audiobook component and reports royalties, including for its standalone Audiobooks Access tier. Spotify’s Q3 2026 SEC filing says that if a later appeal overturned the bundle ruling, potential liability for March 1, 2024–September 30, 2026 would be about €538 million, separate from penalties and interest; the company also says direct publisher deals could offset some exposure.

What changed in Premium—and why it matters

Spotify added up to 15 hours of audiobook listening to Premium in late 2023 and, starting with March 2024 reporting, treated Premium as a bundled subscription for U.S. mechanical royalty purposes. That classification can reduce the revenue base used to calculate songwriter and publisher mechanicals under Copyright Royalty Board regulations. (law.justia.com)

What the court has decided so far

On January 28, 2025, the court dismissed the MLC’s original complaint with prejudice, holding that Premium qualifies as a bundle as a matter of law. On September 1, 2026, the judge denied the MLC’s request to take an interlocutory appeal of that bundle ruling and struck Spotify’s ‘unclean hands’ defense. (law.justia.com) (law.justia.com)

What’s still in dispute

After reconsideration, the court let the MLC file an amended complaint focused on different questions: whether Spotify improperly valued the audiobook component within Premium and whether it misreported royalties, including for the Audiobooks Access tier. Discovery has included orders for Spotify to produce surveys and analyses related to its $9.99 Audiobooks Access valuation. Litigation on these calculation and reporting issues is ongoing. (law.justia.com) (app.midpage.ai)

Money at stake

Spotify’s September 30, 2026 Form 6‑K states that if the MLC ultimately succeeded in overturning the bundle ruling on appeal, additional royalties due for March 1, 2024–September 30, 2026 would be approximately €538 million, plus unquantified penalties and interest; Spotify says any liability would be partially offset by direct deals with publishers. The filing does not quantify possible exposure tied specifically to the amended calculation/reporting claims. (sec.gov)

The bigger picture for creator payouts

The case sits alongside parallel market moves: several major publishers have inked direct U.S. mechanical deals with Spotify that bypass the CRB bundling discount—separate from the MLC litigation—signaling evolving approaches to how streaming bundles allocate value between music and other audio. (musicbusinessworldwide.com)

FROM THE CREATOR

@MLC_US

The creator’s own post or video.

Watch ↗